|
Uncertainty!
By Ronald W. Rogé, MS, CFP®
 |
Ronald W. Rogé,
MS, CFP®
Chairman & CEO
|
There’s an old saying on Wall Street that markets can live with good
news and they can live with bad news, but they can’t live with
uncertainty. There’s an awful lot of uncertainty on Wall Street these
days and that’s why there’s so much volatility in the markets.
That uncertainty is derived from a number of overlapping economic and financial factors.
The Subprime Mortgage Problem
Let’s begin with the subprime mortgage crisis, which has effectively
capsized the domestic housing market. At the current rate of sales, it
would take more than 10 months to move the inventory of unsold homes,
which is twice the normal time. In some areas of the country, that time
is estimated to be over a year. Economists say inventories are, in
fact, even higher because many wishing to sell have simply pulled their
properties off the market because of falling prices. It will require a
pricing correction on the order of 15% to 20% over the next few years
to clear this very deep backlog.
Overall, the housing picture is grim. In 2007 the median price of an
American single-family home declined for the first time in more than 40
years and sales of those homes fell 13%, the sharpest annual decline in
a quarter-century. Further, permits for new construction – a leading
economic indicator – dropped 34% last year.
The recent and future easing of short-term interest rates by the
Federal Reserve will eventually take some pressure off the housing
market. However, the Fed can’t reduce the federal funds rate much below
1% because of the risk of inflation. So this political move (in an
election year) will undermine the economy over the longer term by
keeping the U.S. dollar weak and increasing inflation. The housing
market probably won’t get back on track in 2008 or 2009. It will take
some time – perhaps three to five years – to wring out the excesses
that stemmed from a combination of low interest rates and lax credit
standards.
The Credit Crisis
Then there’s the credit crisis, which was brought on by the
repackaging of risky subprime mortgages into securities that were then
incorporated into convoluted investment vehicles called derivatives.
And then slicing and dicing those derivatives into more derivatives,
which are highly variable and subject to manipulation.
Subprime and credit derivatives are just the latest sleight of hand
from Wall Street’s ever-resourceful marketing machine. They created a
lucrative (and mostly unregulated) house of cards. Little surprise then
that, after it became apparent it was just about impossible to
accurately price derivative securities, this flawed enterprise suddenly
came apart at the seams, causing write-offs of tens of billions of
dollars at such supposedly smart financial institutions as Citibank,
Bear Sterns, Bank of America, UBS, etc. It’s hard to avoid the
conclusion that the managements of these companies are either stupid or
greedy. If they didn’t know what they were doing, then they were
stupid. If they understood what was going on, then they are greedy.
Either way, they violated their fiduciary duty to their clients and,
ultimately, to all investors while jeopardizing the entire U.S. economy.
The real problem here is that the bond market is so much larger and
more complicated than the stock market and is much more critical to the
U.S. Economy.
Remember when you learned about the planets. There was a photo of the
Sun and a small dot on the Sun, which represented the Earth. It gave us
a perspective of just how big the Sun is compared to the Earth. Well
you can use that visual to give you an idea just how big the bond
market is compared to the stock and commodities markets in terms of
valuation. The U. S. Stock Market alone is valued at almost $22
trillion (excludes global equity market). The N. Y. Times reported last
week that the Credit Default Insurance Market alone is $44.5 trillion,
Mortgage Securities are $7.1 trillion and U. S. Treasuries are $4.4
trillion in size. Then you need to add U. S. Corporate bonds at $5.8
trillion and the rest of the world’s bond market values to give you
some perspective.
So when you hear people try and rationalize by saying that the
Sub-Prime Mortgages are only a certain percent of the mortgage market
and the mortgage market is only a certain percent of the entire bond
market, you should realize that those numbers are meaningless, unless
you know the size of the entire global bond market and its derivatives
compared to the stock and commodities markets around the world. The
magnitude of the problem is much bigger than most folks realize.
An Election Year
Compounding these two uncertainties is the fact that we are in an
election year. Who will be the next president and vice-president? What
will Congress look like? Who will lower taxes? Who will raise taxes?
Who can defend the country best?
This is certainly a very unusual election. It’s the first time since
1952 that either an incumbent president or vice-president is not on the
ticket. It’s the first time a woman and an African-American are running
for the nation’s top office. Both are currently U.S. senators. And the
presumptive Republican nominee is also a current U.S. senator. In
recent times, sitting and former senators have not been particularly
successful in presidential bids (John F. Kennedy was the last).
Conversely, governors of states have had a much better record (Jimmy
Carter, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton and George W. Bush).
The only nice thing about changes in government is that we can take
some comfort in the fact that in our country’s 200-plus-year history we
have somehow managed to survive even the worst of presidents and
governments.
So the bottom line is that, while elections are usually not very
important to the economy and the markets longer term, they do tend to
divert us from focusing on the real issues shorter term.
Global Conflict, Gamesmanship and the Economy
The costs associated with our occupation of Iraq and operations in
Afghanistan have greatly exacerbated the U.S. deficit. It’s also part
of the reason the U.S. dollar has been so week. Travel to the United
Kingdom today and it will cost you $2 to get £1 (one pound sterling).
The dollar is also at record lows against the euro and many other major
currencies. That diminished stature is a reflection of the perceived
economic weakness of the U.S., which is mired in debt and beset by a
slowing economy and troubled financial markets.
Part of the reason the U.S. dollar is no longer in demand is that crude
oil trades in U.S. dollars. With a weak dollar the oil producing
countries will continue to want more dollars for their most valuable
and finite asset, crude oil. This dynamic was borne out with vengeance
earlier this week, as oil hit a record (inflation-adjusted) high and
the greenback was simultaneously slumping to a 35-year low against the
DXY dollar index, a basket of six major currencies that serves as
barometer of the dollar’s overall strength.
With the lack of a practical, long-term energy policy to put this
country on the path to independent domestic energy production, there is
very little hope in sight.
Oddly enough, the lack of having a meaningful independent energy policy
is the root cause of many of our nation’s problems, including the
anemic dollar. Yet I’ve not heard one person running for the nation’s
highest office discuss this shortcoming in any substantive manner.
There is also the U. S. deficit. We continue to run up huge debt by
doing silly things like trying to buy votes in an election year by
sending folks a $600 check under the guise of stimulating the economy.
We are borrowing this money from foreign countries to encourage the
same bad behavior (spending and not saving) that got us in a fix in the
first place.
The U. S. Consumer and the Economy
In the recent past the consumer has come to the rescue of the economy,
preventing recessions or shortening the length of them, because they
borrowed against the rising values of their homes. Folks used this
borrowed money to shop until they dropped while not saving for the
future. Well, Mr. & Mrs. Consumer, the future has just arrived and
you’re feeling the pressure in the form of higher food, energy and
other costs. Your home has recently lost 10% to 20% of its value and
nervous financial institutions have tightened their lending standards,
making it much harder to get a loan. You have no savings for
emergencies and are drifting back to a paycheck-to-paycheck kind of
lifestyle with no safety net and nowhere to turn. Should the economy
continue to slow down or slip into a recession, you might even lose
your job. But don’t worry! The government will bail you out with that
$600 check, money it had to borrow because it has no savings either.
Alright, that’s enough of bad news. I could go on with more, but I
think you get the point by now. Both the government and the people are
living way above their means and now it’s time to change course.
The Good News
Looking at the bright side, we are in a global economy. While a
slowdown in the U.S. economy will obviously have some impact on the
global economy, it will not push rapidly growing countries like China
and India and many emerging markets into a recession. They will
continue to grow, just a little slower, which will actually be
beneficial to those economies longer term by easing inflationary
pressures. The most recent indication of this trend is the World Bank,
which lowered its estimate of China’s economic growth for 2008 (from
10.8% to a still blistering 9.6%) due to cooling global export demand,
particularly from the U.S.
The Prescription
So, what’s the prescription? A serious independent energy policy with
an emphasis on efficiency and cleaner (and renewable) energy sources is
needed to ease dependence on increasingly expensive oil. You may even
begin to hear the “N” word again (that is, nuclear) as the higher cost
of energy and food becomes too painful for the consumer to cope with.
Increasing inflation, higher interest rates and tighter credit will
eventually help this economy emerge from the recession by imposing some
badly needed fiscal discipline, but it will extract a price in doing
so. Lower housing values, less consumer spending and higher food and
energy costs will be the norm for several years to come. The government
may even attempt to stimulate the economy by using the savings to be
gained from winding down operations in Iraq on badly needed
infrastructure maintenance and expansion instead of paying down the
deficit.
The Strategy
I think a good assumption, at this juncture, would be that the dollar
will remain weak and perhaps fall even further. U.S. stocks will remain
weak in a slowing economy and bond spreads will continue to widen
(short rates go down while long rates increase) generating a more
conventional yield curve as we emerge from the recession.
This means adopting a more defensive asset allocation strategy by:
- Creating the proper risk controlled asset allocation (stocks, bonds and cash) that meets your tolerance for risk (volatility).
- Placing a premium on high quality domestic stocks and bonds.
- Large-cap multi-national stocks (dividend paying) are at good valuations at these levels.
-
Municipal bonds are extremely attractive right now for tax-conscious
investors as are high-quality foreign bonds. (Increase taxes on the
wealthy and the demand for municipal bonds will go up, creating a
profit opportunity).
- Increasing holdings of foreign equities (less exposure to the dollar).
- An allocation of 20% to 50% can be in foreign equities.
- Both high quality and emerging market equities.
- Employ
limited portfolio hedging tactics to reduce some of the downside risk
for the near-term, until we see some evidence that the economy is
beginning to recover.
- Focus the
portfolio’s securities by overweighting promising areas that will have
pricing flexibility in an inflationary environment and will maintain
the purchasing power of your portfolio.
- Areas such as agriculture, energy, natural resources, precious metals and health care.
-
Infrastructure companies, should we get a government that will try to
stimulate the economy through public works projects (deficit gets
bigger and dollar stays very weak or declines further).
In
due course, excesses and malfeasance will be wrung out of the system,
regulatory adjustments will be made and the economy will regain its
balance--it always does. And – not least – Wall Street will sober up
from its latest bout of greed and rediscover its sense of fiduciary
responsibility to investors large and small alike.
In the meantime, as we navigate this correction, we can draw from the
lessons of past market dislocations. Since 1980, the U.S. has
experienced four recessions that have each lasted an average of 9 ½
months. We will use this time to devise strategies and implement
tactics that will help to preserve your portfolio’s purchasing power in
these uncertain times and be ready for the economy to emerge from the
recession.
|